Published on 10 Mar 2013
ALL INDIA BAMCEF UNIFICATION CONFERENCE HELD AT Dr.B. R. AMBEDKAR BHAVAN,DADAR,MUMBAI ON 2ND AND 3RD MARCH 2013. Mr.PALASH BISWAS (JOURNALIST -KOLKATA) DELIVERING HER SPEECH.
Asianet news editor Sindhu Suryakumar gets death threats for her comments on Goddess Durga #Vaw #WTFnews Goddess Durga debate, sedition charges and death threats: Senior Journalist Sindhu Sooryakumar on the hate campaign against her
Asianet news editor Sindhu Suryakumar gets death threats for her comments on Goddess Durga #Vaw #WTFnews
A sustained misinformation campaign against Asianet News Chief Coordinating Editor Sindhu Sooryakumar is on social media platforms since Friday. Her phone number was widely distributed on social media exhorting the public to ring her up for "denigrating Durga." Pestered by thousands of threat calls and abuses for three days, Sooryakumar filed a complaint with the police. Still, the campaigncontinues, there is no end to threat calls and personal abuse on public platforms.The rabid campaign against the journalist began after a television debate she hosted on Friday evening discussed union minister Smriti Irani's Goddess Durga statements in Rajya Sabha. The social media messages painted that Sooryakumar denigrated Durga.
Sindhu Sooryakumar talks in detail on the News Hour debate she hosted and the hate campaign that ensued.
The social media campaign against you continues still. Death threat calls and abuses are still on. What was behind the hate campaign against you? What happened during the News Hour programme?
Smriti Irani presented a leaflet on Mahishasura Day observance at JNU in the Parliament. The Opposition protested in the Rajya Sabha, pointing out that bringing such leaflets published by fringe groups will set a bad precedence. The News Hour discussed the issue on Friday evening. VV Rajesh represented the BJP in the debate. MB Rajesh MP and Anto Antony presented the views of the CPM and the Congress respectively. In the programme, VV Rajesh repeated Smriti Irani's statement that the leaflet painted Goddess Durga as a sex worker. Not even once, did I quote his statement. My question was how Smriti Irani could cite the references in the leaflet to prove the allegations of sedition. I repeatedly sought the BJP spokesperson's explanation on how it amounted to sedition.
How a comment, which may be considered blasphemous, would come under sedition law? Besides, some tribes in Uttar Pradesh, Bihar andOdisha celebrate Mahishasura Jayanti. If that is part of their belief, how can they be blamed? On the other hand, there are no objections to celebrations of Durgashtami and Durga Jayanti. These were the issues raised at the debate. In his reply, Rajesh praised pluralism. But he claimed that things propagated through the leaflet would instill separatist tendencies among students and pit them against each other. Then I pointed out that such programmes used to be held in the campus earlier as well and people like BJP Udith Raj had participated in the event in the past.
In the half an hour discussion, I never raised the question "what is wrong calling Durga a sex worker?" Nor did I say that it was a matter of freedom of expression, as is propagated by them. Please watch the video. You will understand what transpired.
What happened next?
After 8:30 pm on Friday, I started getting phone calls stating that I made denigrating comments on Durga. In the beginning, I did not have any clue on what was evolving. I did not attend many calls either.VV Rajesh rang me up in the morning and said that there was a misinformation campaign going on against me. He informed that a Whatsaapp message was doing rounds against me.
What did the callers say. What was your police complaint?
They said they won't let me live in peace and will destroy my family. The comments were sexist and abusive. I filed a police complaint when I couldn't take it anymore. I gave them details of the calls I attended. For the past three days my mobile phone has been inundated with abusive calls, which is still continuing. The messages circulated from pro-BJP, pro-Sangh Facebook profiles published my phone number and exhorted people to call me. The FB posts wrongly quoted me as saying " Sindhu Sooryakumar asks what's wrong if someone calls Goddess Durga a sex worker." "Sindhu Sooryakumar is a sex worker. This is her phone number. Call her to protest," such messages circulated on pro-BJP, pro-Sangh Facebook profiles. Such messages are also circulating via Whatsapp.
Who do you think is behind this?
I strongly believe that the RSS is behind this campaign. Because it is through their social media network – from India as well as the Middle East – that these messages are circulating. I do not think this is a natural response to a news program. This is a planned campaign hatched from the RSS camp. I am forced to believe that RSS is encouraging a culture that is abusive to women. I wish I were wrong. But this is my experience. Unless RSS disowns this hate campaign, I will continue to believe this campaign was done at their behest.
I called BJP Spokesperson V.V Rajesh (who attended the News Hour show) on Saturday evening and said I was going to file a complaint. "No BJP worker will do this. You go ahead with the complaint. I will cooperate with any investigation. I will tell the police that you have not said anything abusive about Goddess Durga," he told me. I asked him then why is BJP not announcing this as a party position. Why can't they issue a statement? Rajesh replied that BJP Kerala president Kummanam Rajashekharan had to be consulted.
As of now, there has been no response from the BJP. I have shared the police complaint with the Kerala Pradesh Congress CommitteePresident, the CPIM State Secretary, the BJP President, the DGP, the Home Minister, and the Chief Minister. I expect that Kummanam Rajashekharan will watch the News Hour show I hosted, see the truth and issue a statement denouncing the hate campaign against me. As a political leader he has the responsibility to respond. If he has believes in the freedom of expression, I trust that he will issue a statement.
Are you receiving calls even after the police complaint?
There are no signs of the abusive calls stopping. When people call from their own mobile phones, it shows they have no fear of the law. The police have filed charges against a few of them. If the charges against them are not strong, I will move court with a private complaint. I stand by what I said. I will not allow anyone to challenge my freedom of speech and right to live.
Do people who call identify themselves as party functionaries?
Not everyone. But some said they were either RSS or BJP activists. Most of them asked me three questions: Why do you dislike Narendra Modi. Why can't you acknowledge RSS. What is your problem with the BJP.
Asianet new editor Sindhu Suryakumar gets life threat for allegedly 'demeaning Goddess Durga'
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, FEB 28: Asianet News chief co-ordinating editor Sindhu Suryakumar has lodged a complaint with the City Police Commissioner after she received death threats over phone from anonymous callers.
The callers made death threats against the scribe, besides casting aspersions on her character.
Ms. Suryakumar received over a thousand such calls in two days following rumours on social media that she made derogatory remarks against goddess Durga during 'News Hour' programme.
CPI(M) State secretary Kodiyeri Balakrishnan cited the development as proof of attempts by the Sangh Parivar to muzzle the media.
In a Facebook post on Sunday, Kodiyeri charged the Sangh Parivar with making death threats against Sindhu Suryakumar following her objective analysis of the JNU row.
The Sangh Parivar had publicised her mobile, landline numbers and also her Facebook account, and had instigated others to unleash an attack on her, he wrote.
Sindhu, while hosting a debate on Sitaram Yechury and Union Minister Smriti Irani locking horns in Parliament over goddess Durga, had made references to Irani's invoking Durga in Parliament, Kodiyeri wrote.
The Sangh Parivar has given a spin to this and levelled baseless allegations against Sindhu that she demeaned Durga, he added.
This sent out a message that the Sangh Parivar would target any journalist who would not toe their line, the Facebook post said.
A section of journalists had concocted proof at the behest of Prime Minister Narendra Modi to portray students of JNU as anti-nationals, Kodiyeri wrote, adding that through the death threat to Asianet scribe, Sangh Parivar has made it clear they will make life hard for anyone willing to do objective journalism in Kerala.
"This (death threat to Sindhu Suryakumar) is but another version of the hooliganism that 'Sanghis' in black robes unleashed against students, teachers, and journalists at Patiala House courts complex," Kodiyeri opined.
He concluded his post demanding that the State police must apprehend and bring to justice at the earliest those who made the life threat
THE HIMALAYAN TALK: PALASH BISWAS CRITICAL OF BAMCEF LEADERSHIP
[Palash Biswas, one of the BAMCEF leaders and editors for Indian Express spoke to us from Kolkata today and criticized BAMCEF leadership in New Delhi, which according to him, is messing up with Nepalese indigenous peoples also.
He also flayed MP Jay Narayan Prasad Nishad, who recently offered a Puja in his New Delhi home for Narendra Modi's victory in 2014.]