Fwd: [bangla-vision] Nationalism-secularism-democracy...Shirk or Debatable

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Kashmir Study Circle <ksc687@yahoo.com>
Date: Sat, Oct 23, 2010 at 7:58 PM
Subject: [bangla-vision] Nationalism-secularism-democracy...Shirk or Debatable
To: ksc687@yahoo.com
Cc: ksc687@yahoo.com

 

Nationalism-secularism-democracy...Shirk or Debatable   Salam wd prays plz read my reply to KGK, declaring nationalism-secularism-democracy as SHIRK…..thx   Till the conception of Nationalism is not rejected by whole UMMAH...I mean by all Muslim World by keeping open their borders for all Muslims...only Nationalism can secure our spiritual & moral valves....As in any foreign country hw can one hide his nationality, wh is their his security & identity...Even in Pakistan based on Islam...Sinndhy,punjabe,Pathan, Baloachee....is not ready to eliminate his national ego...hw can Kashmire b safe their by eliminating Nationalism...Till the KHALAFAT; conception of nationalism means....but the spiritual way is not to create nationalism ego...So under present practical observation to treat it as Shirik is debatable….As in reply to Nehru G Allama Iqbal says… Nationalism is the sense of love of one's country & even readiness to die for its honor is a part of the Muslim's faith: it comes into conflict wd Islam only wn it begins to play the role of a political concept & claims to b a principle of human solidarity demanding that Islam should recede to the background of a mere private opinion & cease to b a living factor in the national life...It becomes a problem for Muslims only in countries where they happen to b in a minority,& nationalism demands their complete self-effacement .In majority countries Islam accommodates nationalism; for there Islam & nationalism r practically identical; in minority countries it is justified in seeking self-determination as a cultural unit. In either case, it is thoroughly consistent wd itself.   Abt secularism...it is only in books even wdin such states claiming champion of secularism..like US,India...West....Practically their policies, administration, even court decisions...influenced wd religious sentiments....Otherwise if implemented seriously US will never support illegal acts of Israel..never would have invaded Muslim states..India would have accepted the right of self determination of Kashmires...Sudan would have accepted right of DAfur...Secularism is exposed by differentiating East Taymoor wd Kashmir...Even socialist system in USSR was influenced by Church...So secularism if implemented by those claiming its champion...the best option...but is in books only...No doubt such secularism wd no room in Islam ...being NEZAME HSYAT FOR ALLAM..complete guideline,,wd protection of minorities..real scene of secularism...   What abt those Islamic scholars...ulmas...groups...who believe in democracy while contesting or in past contested elections wd fair intentions in Muslim countries for imposing Islamic laws...& in occupied soils like Kashmir to raise voice i...n assembly against illegal occupation...even Ikhwanul Muslemoon in Egypt have also contested recently decided to participate in elections..Hisbullah..also contested...Hamas in power in Ghaza only after contesting elections... If they all have committed SHIRK...80% Muslims cast votes have faith wd democracy...then hw much r wdout SHIRK...So instead of Shirk,wh is big crime plz treat it also in first stage as debatable issue....thx   Wd regards Eng.Mehmood Kashmir Study Circle A neutral institution engaged in mission…research-media-charity….wdout fundraising & publicity for thirteen years. All records of its claim safe…open for all…thx

__._,_.___

--
Palash Biswas
Pl Read:
http://nandigramunited-banga.blogspot.com/